“ Been here a few times. Have never been disappointed. Took my Dad, Aunt and Sister for lunch yesterday. Everyone ordered the Shrimp & Clam Strip Platters. I had the Zuppa Di Pesce. Food was Amazing!!! Ashley was Great!! Anthony & Michael stopped by the table to say Hello. My Dad has something negative to say no matter where we take him. He Loved everything!! Even the fries and coleslaw!! He couldn’t believe the amount of food he got or the size of the Shrimp!! Great Job Everyone. We will all definitely be back! ”

“ I wish I had more pics because these don't do the place justice. They have come a long way since they opened! Besides great pizza and apps, big meaty wings and fresh tenders, salads, sandwiches, and build-your-own burgers, the newly added lobster rolls and fried seafood are out of this world! And super reasonable compared to higher end seafood restaurants in the area! The batter is so nice and light and crispy, even by the time take-out gets home! I hear they have a new chef, formally from a local seafood restaurant and it is amazing! The place is super casual and not too big. A few booths, some high tops and a long bar, with big screen TVs and a pool table. Seems to be a great neighborhood spot to watch football. The owner, Anthony, is super nice and works hard in the kitchen and the staff hustles on the floor and behind the bar. (especially Ashley!) Our new go-to-place for convenience and great food at reasonable prices! Good luck, team. Keep up the great work! ”

“ I love the atmosphere of this restaurant. It has limited parking and it has good service. The pies came out a few minutes after I arrived. I ordered three pies for pick-up. A large "Pepperoni, Bacon and Mozzarella", a small "Chicken Pesto", and small "Hot Oil". I personally really loved the "Hot Oil". It will creep up on you. We paid a total of 56. I'll comeback again. ”

“ Nicky’s Place in East Haven is the best spot for amazing food and good vibes! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with incredible service. Ashley, the bartender, is an absolute gem—fun, down-to-earth, and always delivering top-notch service with a smile. She keeps the good times rolling. Anthony, the owner, is a stand-up guy who’s super friendly and genuinely cares about his customers. You can tell this place is run with passion and heart. The pizza is absolutely bomb, with the perfect crust and flavorful toppings. The sandwiches are just as amazing, with fresh, soft bread that melts in your mouth. To top it all off, they’ve got a Deep Six Arcade game, bringing the perfect retro vibe to your visit. It’s so much fun to play while enjoying your meal. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or hanging out with friends, Nicky’s Place is the ultimate spot in East Haven for incredible eats and great vibes. Highly recommend! ”

“ The food is amazing, portions are outstanding and pricing is so reasonable! Plus the owner was so sweet and came to our table to introduce himself and give some background to his family business. Will def come back!! ... ”

“ A destination spot in East Haven Ct. From the moment you enter your treated like family. No family dinner is complete without great food and that is just what you will get when you dine here. From great season inspiring drinks to elegant meals inspired and prepared with love and care. From their Pizza to their wings as well as fantastic pasta dishes you will not be disappointed. ”

“ Nicky’s is a fantastic spot, especially if you're looking for great gluten-free dining options. The sausage is amazing, and they are incredibly careful with allergies and sensitivities. Highly recommended! The Lobster Roll Pie was the perfect combination of a traditional lobster roll and a white pizza pie. While slightly pricier than other items offered on the menu, the lobster meat was tender, high quality, and plentiful. Well worth it, and perfect for a summer night in New England! ”

“ Had a hot oil pizza for a first time and it was delicious! My bae loved the lobster roll. ”